Time to say “Yes”
Published: 11 November 2026
– When it comes to protest and dissent, is saying “yes” now as important as saying “no”
By Rev Matthew Smith
Historically, religious dissent was defined by what people rejected, but modern Unitarianism should be defined by what it embraces. By celebrating diversity in beliefs, experiences and our individual understanding of beauty, Unitarians can build inclusive communities that recognise there are many different ways to find truth, meaning and spiritual fulfilment.
Consider the simplicity of some eighteenth-century Meeting Houses. No stained glass or religious icons but a bright, mostly unadorned, building can be just as beautiful as a gothic parish church with its statues and stained glass.
Meeting Houses were built that way because the Dissenters thought this is what God wanted – that God didn’t approve of all that imagery and sacramentalism. Early Dissenters were the ones who said “no”. To Dissent is to say “no!” They said “no” to bishops, to prayer books imposed by the state, and to the making of intermediaries between God and humankind – the priest, the saints and so on.
There was also an aesthetic “yes” at the heart of that “no”. Protestantism was powered by the printing press – by being able to read the Bible in one’s mother tongue. There was a love of seeing the printed word, of being able to hold the scripture in one’s hand and to read – to be able to sing hymns out of a hymn book in one’s own tongue.
Being a Dissenter was arguably mainly though a “no” to the Rites of the Church of the England (with a “yes” to a plainer aesthetic focused on the truth and perceived beauty of Scripture – and clear light through the windows to read by).
Unitarians today, however, are a pluralistic movement. We unite liberal Christians, with humanists, agnostics, atheists, and folks with an Earth-centred spirituality.
It makes much less sense to be people of the no – Dissenters – when most people in Britain aren’t active in the CofE – or the Church of Scotland or the Church in Wales either!
People coming into our movement seek affirmation. Are LGBT folk loved by God as much as straight folks? “Yes”. Should we appreciate there is truth and beauty in other religions and philosophies? “Yes”. Should we appreciate the wholeness of the body and not solely venerate free thinking? “Yes”. Should we be willing to try out new rituals? “Yes”. This yes is more interested in making connections between the good than it is in a kind of iconoclastic purity characteristic of a great big “no”.
We must nurture congregations and communities that say a great big aesthetic and ethical “yes”. And perhaps our “yeses” say something about our own personal aesthetic sense almost as much as our ethics. Are you doubtful? Consider our own unique personalities? Here are two mental pictures for you. Imagine a study space completely tidy – everything you can imagine exactly in the right place. Now imagine entering an old, creaking bookshop with rickety bookcases with mysterious and esoteric titles, with books on the floor, with nooks and crannies that contain unknown treasures that you have to hunt for.
Which of these two images are you more drawn to? The perfectly ordered space or the mysterious bookshop. We will not all make the same choice. Is the tidy office somehow morally superior to the old bookshop? An old untidy bookshop is not necessarily an example of moral failure. It might hold its own beauty and wisdom. Accordingly, our personal growth can come from surprises round the corner as much as from that which is clear and ordered. We achieve clarity both through simplification and order, and by being surprised or making unexpected connections.
Humans are different from one another; this has big implications for our shared experience of that celebration of human worth known as Sunday ‘worship’. For some silence is the best moment, for some it is hearing sacred text or poetry, for some a rousing rendition of William Blake’s Jerusalem – for some it may even be the way the light changes in the sanctuary as the sun moves.
Your sense of what is sublime will be different from mine. That sense is part of who we each are as unique individuals and how we wish to express our devotion to what we feel matters most. There is a worthwhile conversation here that we have perhaps barely begun.
